Mon 20 Aug 2007
There was a family gathering yesterday on my side of the family. I got to see my parents, siblings, uncles and cousins again, some for the last time before we leave for our trip. We talked a little bit about the climate and culture of South Korea, as well as the political stability of the region. The discussion turned to the Korean hostages in Afghanistan and we were jokingly asked if our faces would soon be appearing on their TV screens asking for help from Canadians to be released.
Both of the organizations we looked at working with have the same policy when it comes to hostage takings. If Ana and/or I were kidnapped the organization that employs us would not pay any ransom demands to have us released. This may sound heartless but it makes a lot of sense. Any money given to an organization willing to kidnap someone for it could only go to support more violence. Christian Peacemaker Teams has the same policy and refused to pay to have their workers released in Iraq.
I’m not sure if the Korean aid workers currently being held hostage felt that they would be safe because they were protected by God, because their cause was noble enough, or because the situation just wasn’t that bad. It would be interesting to hear if they had any sort of contingency plan for this kind of scenario. It is obviously a tragic situation, and it’s impossibly to know how one would react in their shoes, but I would like to think that I would refuse to trade my freedom for that of a terrorist prisoner. I don’t believe that every Taliban prisoner is a bloodthirsty savage, but it just doesn’t sound like a fair trade to me.
August 21st, 2007 at 3:13 pm
Will,
Couldn’t agree with you more. If you negotiate and pay off people willing to kidnap, hijack or other such behaviour this will only serve to encourage more.
Now exactly what a tourbus full of Korean christians were doing in Kandahar province remains a bit of a mystery to me and one might/should ask the question if these folks were looking for a quick way to heaven.
In your case and in the case of many christian NGOs I think things are more sensible. Rules no. 1 for going into a war zone ‘don’t unless you have been issued at least six heavily armed foreign troops as protection and will be living on base behind machine gun nests, bunkers and high walls’ or ‘don’t unless you know the area well, have been briefed on local customs and adopt a low key/blend in with locals as much as possible, routine’. I don’t think the koreans did either.
Cheers,
P